Theme: Still Life
Tools of the Trade by Winnie Gustafson
Judge 1 Comments:Too many interesting images to look at, my eye got confused as to the main subject. Perhaps too many different texture effects for one image.
Judge 2 Comments:The perspective is off, not sure what I was looking at, the horse shoes in middle of image are bigger than man.
Judge 3 Comments:This is a collage, rather than a still life; The individual elements are interesting, but the arrangement, and choice of scale do not work. Tool box is blown out. A more compelling image might be a closeup of the horsheshoer's hand working on the horse's hoof, with the toolbox (in real scale) nearby.
Judge 1 Comments:Too many interesting images to look at, my eye got confused as to the main subject. Perhaps too many different texture effects for one image.
Judge 2 Comments:The perspective is off, not sure what I was looking at, the horse shoes in middle of image are bigger than man.
Judge 3 Comments:This is a collage, rather than a still life; The individual elements are interesting, but the arrangement, and choice of scale do not work. Tool box is blown out. A more compelling image might be a closeup of the horsheshoer's hand working on the horse's hoof, with the toolbox (in real scale) nearby.
Tools of the Trade by Winnie Gustafson
Judge 1 Comments:Too many interesting images to look at, my eye got confused as to the main subject. Perhaps too many different texture effects for one image.
Judge 2 Comments:The perspective is off, not sure what I was looking at, the horse shoes in middle of image are bigger than man.
Judge 3 Comments:This is a collage, rather than a still life; The individual elements are interesting, but the arrangement, and choice of scale do not work. Tool box is blown out. A more compelling image might be a closeup of the horsheshoer's hand working on the horse's hoof, with the toolbox (in real scale) nearby.
Judge 1 Comments:Too many interesting images to look at, my eye got confused as to the main subject. Perhaps too many different texture effects for one image.
Judge 2 Comments:The perspective is off, not sure what I was looking at, the horse shoes in middle of image are bigger than man.
Judge 3 Comments:This is a collage, rather than a still life; The individual elements are interesting, but the arrangement, and choice of scale do not work. Tool box is blown out. A more compelling image might be a closeup of the horsheshoer's hand working on the horse's hoof, with the toolbox (in real scale) nearby.
